Skip to main content
Since 1987 • Jenison, MI
Maintenance & DIY

How to Change Your Furnace Filter, Step by Step

Mike Mazure9 min read

Give me five minutes and a flashlight and I'll get you through this. You don't need tools, and if you go in the order below there's nothing on the furnace you can hurt.

I'm writing it out because "change your filter" is the most repeated advice in my trade and almost nobody explains how. People stand in the basement holding a filter from the hardware store, looking at a furnace with three panels and no labels, and they guess. Sometimes the guess is fine. Sometimes I find the filter in backwards, or in the wrong slot, or wedged in with an inch of open air down one side.

How often to change it is a separate question, and I've covered that here. This one is just the how.

Before You Buy Anything

Don't go to the store first. Go to the furnace first.

Pull the old filter (steps below) and read the edge. The size is printed on the cardboard frame, something like 16x25x1 or 20x25x4. Take a picture of it with your phone. While you're at it, take a picture of the whole furnace and wherever the filter came out of. That photo answers most of the questions a store clerk or I would ask you.

If the printing has worn off, measure the slot itself: width, height, and depth. Filter sizes are nominal, which means a 16x25x1 actually measures closer to 15.5 by 24.5 by three-quarters. Round your measurement up to the nearest standard size and you'll land on the right one.

Buy two or three while you're there. You'll need them, and the next change goes faster when the filter is already sitting next to the furnace.

Where the Filter Lives

This is the part that trips people up, because there are four common spots and some houses use one you wouldn't expect.

A slot in the side of the furnace. Most common in the basements around here. Look low on the furnace, where the big return duct comes in, for a narrow slot with a metal or cardboard cover. Sometimes it's just a slit with the filter's edge showing.

Inside the bottom of the furnace. Some older units hide it behind the lower front panel, right below the blower. You lift the panel off (it usually just pulls up and out) and the filter is lying in there or standing on a rack.

A return grille in a wall or ceiling. Common in houses where the furnace is in a closet or an attic. The big grille in the hallway, usually the largest one in the house, swings open on two latches and the filter sits right behind it.

A media cabinet. A box four or five inches thick bolted between the return duct and the furnace, with a removable door on the front. If you have one, your filter is the thick pleated kind and you'll be changing it far less often.

If you've looked in all four places and come up empty, stop and call. A furnace with no filter at all is more common than you'd think, and it's worth knowing about.

Changing It, One Step at a Time

  1. Turn the furnace off. Set the thermostat to off, or use the switch on or next to the furnace that looks like a light switch. With the blower running, the old filter is sucked tight against the opening and anything you knock loose goes straight into the blower wheel.
  2. Open the slot or cabinet. Slide the cover off, pop the door, or unlatch the grille. Set the cover somewhere you'll see it — I'll come back to why.
  3. Note which way the old filter faces before you pull it. Look for the arrow on its edge. That tells you how the last person put it in, which is usually but not always right.
  4. Slide the old one out slowly. It's full of dust, and yanking it shakes that dust all over the basement floor. Hold it flat and put it straight into a trash bag.
  5. Look at the empty slot. Quick look with the flashlight for anything that doesn't belong: a second filter stuck behind the first, a bent rail, an old piece of cardboard, a dead mouse. It happens.
  6. Check the arrow on the new filter. It points in the direction the air moves, which is toward the furnace. In a side slot, that means the arrow faces the furnace cabinet. In a ceiling or wall grille, it faces into the duct, away from the room.
  7. Slide the new filter in all the way. It should sit square with no gap at the edges. If you have to bend it to fit, it's the wrong size.
  8. Put the cover back on. Then turn the furnace back on and make sure the blower starts.
  9. Write the date on the edge of the new filter with a marker. Next time, you'll know exactly how long it's been in there.

Keep a spare filter taped to the side of the return duct or leaning against the furnace. When the date on the old one says it's time, you don't have to make a store run first, and the job actually gets done.

What a Dirty Filter Tells You

Hold the old filter up to a light. A clean one, you can see light through it easily. A filter that's done is gray or brown all over the incoming side and you can barely see through it.

A few things worth noticing:

It's caked solid after a short time. You might have a lot of dust from a renovation, pets, or a leaky return duct pulling in basement or attic air. Worth mentioning at your next tune-up.

It's bowed or sucked in at the middle. The filter is too restrictive for the system, or it waited too long. Either way the blower was fighting hard. Furnaces that struggle for air run hot and can trip their safety switch, which shows up as a furnace that shuts off and restarts over and over.

It's clean on one edge and dirty in the middle, or the other way around. Air was going around it. Check the size and the fit.

It's wet or rusty. That's a different problem, usually condensation from the AC coil or a high-efficiency furnace drain. Have somebody look at it.

Five Mistakes I See All the Time

I was at a house in Jenison not long ago for a furnace that kept shutting itself off. Filter slot looked fine from the outside. When I pulled the filter, there was a second one behind it, the old one, still in there from who knows when. The owner had been sliding new filters in front of it for a couple of years. Two filters, one of them solid gray, and a blower working itself to death trying to pull air through both.

That one's on the list. Here's the rest.

Wrong size, leaving a gap. A filter that's an inch short leaves a strip of open slot — and air always takes the easy way around. You end up with a clean-looking filter and a dirty coil. The fix is the right size, not foam tape.

Backwards. Air pushes the filter against its support side when the arrow's right. Backwards, some pleated filters collapse inward over time, and a few kinds don't catch as well.

Forgetting the cover. An open filter slot is a big hole in the return side of the system. The furnace pulls basement air through it instead of house air, and if you've got a gas water heater nearby, it can mess with how that water heater vents. Put the cover back.

Filters in two places. A filter in the hallway grille and another at the furnace means double the resistance. Use one location.

Going too fine without asking. A high-MERV filter in a 1-inch slot can choke a furnace that wasn't built for it. MERV and HEPA are their own conversation, and the short version is that thicker usually beats finer.

When It's Not a Filter Problem

If you change the filter and the furnace still runs and runs without warming the house, or keeps shutting off, or makes noises it didn't make before, a filter wasn't the problem. Same if there's a burning smell that hangs on past the first few minutes of the season, or water around the base.

That's when you call. If it's after hours and the house is getting cold, we take emergency calls day and night. If it can wait, book a regular visit and we'll look at the whole system, including that filter slot. Our Comfort Plan gets you priority scheduling and 15% off repairs if you'd rather not think about it at all.

The Bottom Line

Turn the furnace off, find the slot, and read the size off the old filter before you shop. Slide the new one in with the arrow pointing toward the furnace, make sure it fits square with no gaps, put the cover back, and write the date on it. One filter in one place, the right size, and the right direction covers almost everything that goes wrong with this job. If you can't find the filter or the furnace still acts up after a fresh one, call us at (616) 669-8085.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which way does the arrow on a furnace filter point?
Toward the furnace. The arrow shows the direction the air travels, and air travels from your house, through the return duct, into the furnace. If the filter sits in a slot on the side of a furnace with the blower below it, the arrow points at the furnace cabinet. If it's in a ceiling or wall grille, the arrow points into the grille, away from the room. When in doubt, follow the duct with your eyes and point the arrow the way the air is going.
Do I need to turn the furnace off to change the filter?
You should. Flip the thermostat to off, or use the switch on or next to the furnace that looks like a light switch. With the blower running, the old filter is pulled tight against the slot and whatever dust shakes loose gets sucked straight into the blower. It's a two-second step. Just remember to turn it back on, because I've been called out for a dead furnace more than once that turned out to be a switch somebody forgot.
What if I can't find the size printed on my filter?
Measure the slot, not the old filter, and round to the nearest standard size. Filters are sold by nominal size, so a 16x25x1 is actually a bit smaller than sixteen by twenty-five. If your measurements don't match anything on the shelf, take a photo of the furnace's data plate and the slot and call us. Some older units and media cabinets take odd sizes, and guessing usually means a gap the air goes around.
Can I put a filter in the return grille and one at the furnace too?
Pick one. Two filters in a row double the resistance the blower has to fight, and most systems weren't designed for that. If your house has a filter grille in the hallway ceiling and a slot at the furnace, use the one the installer intended, which is usually the furnace, and leave the other empty. If you're not sure which is which, ask whoever services the furnace next time.
Is a 4-inch media filter harder to change than a 1-inch one?
Not really, it's just a different box. Most media cabinets have a door that pops off or swings open, and the filter slides out on a track. The main thing is getting the right brand-compatible size, because media cabinets aren't all the same depth or width. The good news is you're doing it a couple of times a year instead of every month or two.

Need help with your HVAC system?

Talk directly to Mike, the owner. No call centers, no sales pressure. Just honest answers from a family business that's served West Michigan since 1987.

Related Services

Need help from a real technician? Here's what Mazure's can do for you across West Michigan.

Related Articles

Call NowSchedule